"There is a type of person who has a quality about him that sets him apart from other and more ordinary human beings. Such a person has an instinct which is usually found only in small children, an instinct to establish immediate and vital contact between himself and all things in the world. Certainly the hunchback was of this type" (20).
The relationship between Miss Amelia, the hunchback, and Marvin Macy is that of a love triangle. While the "love" is not always romantic, each character is allured by, or is drawn to, the "oppositeness" of another character. For example, Miss Amelia develops love for the hunchback because because he is everything she is not. His social and child-like personality paired with his simple mischeviousness nicely compliments her need for oder. Similarly, Cousin Lymon finds excitement in Marvin Macy because his character appeals to his interest in crime. While I'm skeptical to touch on the relationship between Marvin Macy and Miss Amelia, I think Marvin's interest in Amelia stems from her orderly life. She grew up in a nice home and has a lot going for her, yet she also has a "badass" side to her. I feel that Marvin, a hard criminal, is drawn to her ability to balance these traits, something he is unable to do.
Why do you think Marvin Macy is initially drawn to Miss Amelia?
Welcome to the class blog for E348L: The 20th Century Short Story. Here, we will post our responses to the readings for the day. Each student has to post at least five times in the course of the semester, and will have signed up for posting dates early on. See the Posting Instructions page for details.
I absolutely love this quote, as it describes the hunchback perfectly, giving him a certain innocent aura about him. He has the tendencies of a child, implying his impressionable and social nature. I also agree with the love triangle aspect, as Miss Amelia is clearly drawn to the shallow yet welcoming personality of Cousin Lymon. The attraction Lymon has for Macy is drawn from his infatuation with danger and risk, especially in the criminal mindset, so Macy is a pivotal attractive force for Lymon. In the case of Marvin Macy and Miss Amelia, I believe Miss Amelia was drawn to the companionship and bond Marvin Macy presented her with, while Macy is interested in the stability and order Amelia portrays in her lifestyle and actions. Macy's urge for sexual commitment places their attractions on splitting paths, but the initial love triangle is evident, as each character can gain something they long for from one another.
ReplyDeleteBeing a grim and solitary individual who seeks companionship, why wouldn't Amelia consummate the marriage to Marvin Macy, seeing she can help turn his life in the right direction, away from crime and illegal activity?